Americans Are Eating Their Retirement at Triple the Pre-Pandemic Rate

1 in 17

Nearly 1 in 17 workers with a 401(k) plan raided it last year just to keep the lights on. Not to buy a boat. Not to fund a vacation. To pay medical bills. To stop an eviction. To bury a family member.

Vanguard’s How America Saves 2026 preview puts the 2025 hardship withdrawal rate at 6.0% — triple the 2.0% rate recorded in 2019. Six consecutive annual increases with no sign of reversal.

This is not a retirement crisis. It’s a liquidity crisis hiding inside retirement data.

The Trajectory Nobody Else Is Showing

Most coverage of the Vanguard data treats each year as a standalone headline. Here is what the full time series reveals:

The acceleration is the story. The year-over-year increase hasn’t slowed — it’s held steady at 1.2 percentage points for two straight years. At this pace, nearly 1 in 10 participants would be taking hardship withdrawals by 2028.

We track this as The Cannibalization Rate — one of 85+ indicators in the American Distress Index.

The K-Shape: Record Balances, Record Raids

Here is the fact that makes the hardship rate so revealing: average 401(k) balances are also at record highs. Vanguard reports an average balance of $167,970. The S&P 500 returned 23% in 2024. Headlines say Americans are wealthier than ever.

But the median balance is $44,115 — less than a quarter of the average. That gap tells you who is actually accumulating wealth and who is raiding their account to survive.

This is the K-Shape economy in a single data point. The top of the distribution is compounding record gains. The bottom is liquidating under duress. Both facts are true simultaneously, and neither one alone describes the reality. We explore this divergence across every major category of household finance in The Two-Economy Problem.

What a Hardship Withdrawal Actually Requires

This isn’t a loan. It’s a permanent raid with consequences.

The IRS requires proof of immediate and heavy financial need. You pay income taxes on the withdrawal plus a 10% early withdrawal penalty if you’re under 59.5. The qualifying reasons are narrow:

• Unreimbursed medical expenses
• Preventing eviction or mortgage foreclosure
• Funeral expenses
• Certain home repairs after a federally declared disaster

Nobody does this casually. A 6.0% hardship rate means millions of households have exhausted every other option — credit cards, personal savings, family loans — and are now consuming assets they were never supposed to touch until age 65. For many, the next step after draining retirement is bankruptcy — a decision that carries its own consequences but may be the only path to a reset.

The SECURE 2.0 Question

Critics will note that the SECURE 2.0 Act introduced penalty-free emergency withdrawals of up to $1,000 per year starting in 2024. This likely contributed to some of the jump from 3.6% to 4.8% in 2024.

But the 2025 increase — from 4.8% to 6.0% — happened in SECURE 2.0’s second year, when the novelty factor should have faded. And more fundamentally: making it easier to withdraw doesn’t create the need to withdraw. If households had adequate emergency savings, the penalty-free option would sit unused.

The take-up rate is the signal. Demand for emergency liquidity is so high that millions of Americans used a retirement account as an emergency fund the moment the friction was reduced.

The Converging Signals

The hardship withdrawal rate doesn’t exist in isolation. It’s one of several indicators all pointing the same direction — toward household buffer exhaustion.

The Buffer: The personal savings rate fell to 3.6% in December 2025. That’s less than half the pre-pandemic average of 7.5%, and the thinnest cushion since 2007 — the year before the last crisis.

The $400 Test: The Federal Reserve’s annual SHED survey shows 37% of Americans still can’t cover a $400 emergency with cash. That number has been stuck for three straight years — no improvement despite headline GDP growth and low unemployment.

The Safety Net: Bankrate’s 2025 survey found only 41% of Americans would use savings for a $1,000 emergency, down from 44% a year earlier. Meanwhile, 27% have zero emergency savings — the highest share since 2020.

Debt Service: Household debt payments as a share of disposable income reached 11.26% in Q3 2025 — approaching the pre-pandemic level of 11.73%. Every paycheck has less slack.

These aren’t separate crises. They’re the same crisis measured four ways: American households are running out of buffer. For a deeper look at all five buffer signals and how they’re converging, see our State of the Buffer: Q1 2026 quarterly brief.

Why This Is a Leading Indicator

The ADI tracks Buffer Depletion as its largest component at 30% weight. That’s not an arbitrary editorial choice — it’s based on statistical evidence.

During the 2005–2008 period, buffer depletion indicators (savings rate decline, rising debt service) led debt stress indicators (delinquency, charge-offs) by 9 quarters with a correlation of r=0.69. Households burned through savings first. Then they defaulted.

The pre-GFC pattern with hardship withdrawals specifically: rates rose from approximately 1.5% in 2005 to 2.8% by 2008. The lag between rising hardship withdrawals and rising mortgage delinquency was 18–24 months.

We’re watching that same sequence play out. The 2019-to-2025 trajectory (2.0% → 6.0%) is steeper than the pre-GFC trajectory. The savings rate is in the same range as 2007. Debt service is climbing back toward pre-pandemic peaks. The question is not whether buffers are depleting — it’s how long until depletion converts to default.

Where We Are Now

The American Distress Index currently reads 57.1 — Elevated. Buffer Depletion is the largest single contributor, adding 4.6 points to the composite score through the combination of a falling savings rate and rising debt service.

The hardship withdrawal rate is supporting evidence — it validates what the savings rate and debt service ratio are already showing. When 1 in 17 workers raids their retirement to pay current bills, that’s a revealed-preference confirmation that aggregate buffer metrics are capturing something real.

The ADI doesn’t predict. It tracks what is. And what is, right now, is a household sector burning through every form of buffer simultaneously — liquid savings, emergency funds, and now long-term retirement assets — at a rate that hasn’t been seen since the years before the last financial crisis.

What to Watch

1. Vanguard’s full 2026 report (expected mid-2026) will show whether the 6.0% rate plateaued or continued climbing. Any reading above 6.5% would mark uncharted territory.
2. The savings rate trajectory — if PSAVERT drops below 3.0% while hardship withdrawals stay above 5%, the buffer depletion signal strengthens considerably.
3. Debt delinquency — the historical 18–24 month lag from buffer depletion to debt stress means the 2024–2025 hardship surge should begin showing up in delinquency data by late 2026 or early 2027. Watch FHA delinquency (currently 11.52%) and credit card delinquency for early movement. If you’re already behind on payments, how your mortgage servicer handles the delinquency matters — Mr. Cooper, Freedom Mortgage, and Selene Finance handle large nonbank portfolios where FHA borrowers are concentrated.
4. The $400 Test — the Fed’s SHED survey for 2025 (releasing mid-2026) will show whether the emergency savings floor has finally broken below 37%.

Data current as of March 2026. For the full hardship withdrawal time series and related savings data, see our Hardship Withdrawal Statistics and Savings Rate Statistics roundups. The American Distress Index tracks 85+ indicators of household financial distress across five components. Explore the full dataset at americandefault.org/indicators.