Should I Do a Short Sale?
A short sale lets you walk away cleaner than foreclosure — if you qualify, act early, and get the right terms in writing. With housing affordability at historic lows, more homeowners are weighing this option.
Where are you in this process?
What is a short sale?
A Selling your home for less than you owe on the mortgage, with the lender's approval. Less damaging to your credit than foreclosure.Learn more → is when you sell your home for less than you owe — with your lender's OK. The word "short" means the sale price falls short of the loan balance.
Say you owe $280,000 but the home sells for $230,000. Your lender takes the $230,000 and releases the lien. The $50,000 gap is the deficiency.
What happens to that gap depends on your lender and your state. Many lenders forgive it. Some don't. Getting A court order requiring you to pay the difference between what you owed on your mortgage and what the home sold for at auction. Not allowed in all states.Learn more → forgiveness in writing is the single most important step.
You propose the sale, find a buyer, and submit the offer to the lender.
Your The company that collects your monthly mortgage payments. This may not be the same company that originally gave you the loan. reviews the price and decides whether to accept less than they're owed.
Once the sale closes, you transfer ownership — just like a normal home sale.
Do I qualify?
Lenders need to see two things:
Not always. Many lenders accept "imminent default" — you're current but can prove you won't be able to keep paying. Being behind often speeds approval.
Short sale vs. foreclosure
Both end with you leaving. The differences show up in your credit, legal exposure, and how soon you can buy again.
| Factor | Short Sale | Foreclosure |
|---|---|---|
| Credit score impact | 85-160 point drop | 100-200+ point drop |
| Credit report | "Settled" or "short sale" — 7 years | "Foreclosure" — 7 years |
| FHA mortgage wait | 3 years | 3-7 years |
| Conventional mortgage wait | 2-4 years | 5-7 years |
| Deficiency risk | Negotiable — often waived in writing | State-dependent; often pursued |
| Background checks | No public court record | Public record; may affect clearances |
| Control | You set the timeline | Lender controls everything |
| Relocation help | Some lenders offer $3,000+ | Rare |
How does the process work?
Don't call general customer service. Ask for The process of working with your lender to find an alternative to foreclosure. Includes options like forbearance, loan modification, and short sale.Learn more → directly. Before you call, look up your servicer's track record — large servicers like Mr. Cooper, Freedom Mortgage, and Shellpoint/NewRez each handle short sales differently. See all 76 servicer profiles for complaint records and loss mitigation contacts.
“I'm calling about a short sale. I'm experiencing financial hardship and the property may be worth less than I owe. What documentation do I need? And will you waive the deficiency as part of the approval?”
Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, FHA, VA, and USDA each have their own short sale programs with specific rules. Knowing your investor tells you which program applies. Ask your servicer who owns the loan.
Short sales require lender negotiation that standard agents may not handle well. Ask for references from past short sales.
Usually no. The commission comes from sale proceeds. Some lenders cap it at 5-6%, so confirm upfront.
Why you can't make payments. Be specific — job loss on what date, income dropped from what to what. Use our free generator.
2 years of tax returns, 2-3 months of bank statements, recent pay stubs or termination notice. The Financial Worksheet can help organize this.
Your agent prepares this. Shows what similar homes sell for, supporting the price.
Proof the home is listed at fair market value with a licensed agent.
You sign the offer contingent on lender approval. The lender orders its own valuation and reviews your package.
This takes 30-90 days. Some buyers won't wait. That's the main reason short sales fall through.
This is the most important moment. Keep copies of everything in the Document Tracker. Before you agree, answer three questions:
- Does the letter say the deficiency is forgiven?
- Or does it reserve the right to pursue a A court order requiring you to pay the difference between what you owed on your mortgage and what the home sold for at auction. Not allowed in all states.Learn more →?
- Does it require a promissory note (you repay part of the gap)?
If the letter doesn't clearly waive the deficiency, push back. A A housing counselor approved by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. They provide free help with mortgage problems and can negotiate with your lender. or attorney can help.
“I'm reviewing the short sale approval letter. It does not explicitly waive the deficiency. I need written confirmation that no deficiency will be pursued before I can agree to this sale.”
Some states bar A court order requiring you to pay the difference between what you owed on your mortgage and what the home sold for at auction. Not allowed in all states.Learn more →s on purchase-money mortgages — California is the best-known. But don't assume. Check your state's foreclosure law or ask a A housing counselor approved by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. They provide free help with mortgage problems and can negotiate with your lender..
All proceeds go to the lender. You transfer ownership and vacate by the agreed date.
Some lenders — especially Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac — offer $3,000+ if you vacate on time and leave the home in good condition. Ask your The company that collects your monthly mortgage payments. This may not be the same company that originally gave you the loan..
Will I owe taxes on forgiven debt?
Maybe. The IRS can treat forgiven debt as income. If your lender forgives $50,000, you could get a 1099-C and owe taxes on it.
But many distressed homeowners pay nothing. Three common exclusions:
If your debts exceeded your assets before the forgiveness, you may exclude some or all of the amount. This is the most commonly used exclusion. File IRS Form 982.
Federal exclusion for forgiven mortgage debt on a primary residence. Has been extended multiple times — confirm current status with a tax professional before relying on it.
Debts A court order that eliminates your legal obligation to pay certain debts. Granted at the end of a successful bankruptcy case.Learn more →d in bankruptcy are not taxable income.
Mistakes to avoid
Verbal promises mean nothing. The approval letter must say the deficiency is waived. If it doesn't, assume they can come after you later.
Some lenders approve the sale but require you to repay $10,000-$30,000 later. This is negotiable. Don't accept it blindly.
Most lenders need 45-60 days to process a short sale. If your A public auction where your home is sold to the highest bidder. The lender often bids the amount owed, meaning they take the property.Learn more → is in 30 days, you probably don't have time.
They'll misprice the home, botch the paperwork, or lose the buyer to delays. Ask specifically how many short sales they've closed.
Legitimate agents and attorneys work on commission or contingency. Upfront fees are almost always a scam.
If you have a HELOC or second lien, that lender must also approve the sale. They often get almost nothing from the proceeds. Start that conversation early.
Common questions
From listing to closing, typically 3-6 months. The main variable is lender review time — anywhere from 30 days to 4-6 months for complex cases or second liens.
Both lienholders must agree. The first mortgage gets paid first; the second gets whatever is left — often very little. Second lienholders commonly accept $3,000-$10,000 to release. Start with both lenders at the same time.
Yes, but harder. Lenders are more skeptical about hardship on non-primary residences. The Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act generally only covers primary homes, so the tax exposure can be significant.
Ask for the reason in writing. Common causes: price too low, incomplete docs, or investor rules. A A housing counselor approved by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. They provide free help with mortgage problems and can negotiate with your lender. can help you evaluate next steps — A permanent change to your mortgage terms — such as a lower interest rate or longer repayment period — to make payments more affordable.Learn more →, Voluntarily transferring ownership of your home to the lender to avoid foreclosure. The lender agrees to cancel the remaining mortgage debt.Learn more →, or foreclosure defense.
Yes. Conventional lenders typically require a 2-4 year wait after a short sale vs. 5-7 years after foreclosure. Foreclosure also creates a public court record that shows up on background checks.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a short sale take?
From listing to closing, typically 3-6 months. The main variable is lender review time — anywhere from 30 days to 4-6 months for complex cases or second liens.
What if I have two loans on the house?
Both lienholders must agree. The first mortgage gets paid first; the second gets whatever is left — often very little. Second lienholders commonly accept $3,000-$10,000 to release. Start with both lenders at the same time.
Can I do a short sale on an investment property?
Yes, but harder. Lenders are more skeptical about hardship on non-primary residences. The Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act generally only covers primary homes, so the tax exposure can be significant.
What if the lender says no?
Ask for the reason in writing. Common causes: price too low, incomplete docs, or investor rules. A HUD counselor can help you evaluate next steps — loan modification, deed in lieu, or foreclosure defense.
Is a short sale better for my credit than foreclosure?
Yes. Conventional lenders typically require a 2-4 year wait after a short sale vs. 5-7 years after foreclosure. Foreclosure also creates a public court record that shows up on background checks.
Protect yourself from scams
People in financial distress are prime targets for fraud. Know these rules:
Report fraud: CFPB · FTC · your state attorney general's office.
Is this happening to you?
Do you owe more on your mortgage than your home is worth?
The bigger picture
Short sales rise when household financial stress rises. The American Distress Index tracks the forces that push people toward this decision — savings depletion, rising delinquency, and cost pressure. See our foreclosure statistics for the full picture of filings and delinquency trends.
FHA mortgage delinquency reached 11.52% in late 2024 — more than six times the 1.78% conventional rate. That gap reflects concentrated distress among households with thin The difference between what your home is worth and what you owe on it. If your home is worth $200,000 and you owe $150,000, you have $50,000 in equity. buffers — exactly the people facing short sale decisions.
Foreclosure filing data | FHA delinquency data | American Distress Index
Related guides
Want a professional to review your situation?
A HUD counselor, attorney, or listing agent can help — many at no cost.
We connect you with HUD-approved counselors, legal aid, and state housing agencies. We do not sell your information.
Get the short sale checklist by email.
Document requirements, tax implications, and negotiation tips — one email, no spam.
or Create an Account for full access