Fay Servicing phone numbers, and what to do if you're behind

Complaints about struggling to pay make up 44.7% of Fay Servicing’s CFPB mortgage record. Fay specializes in servicing loans that are already troubled. Fay lists 800-495-7166 for customer service and mortgage help. Mail payments to the address on your current statement.

Fay Servicing phone, hours and written-request routes

Fay prints a customer-care line and a Complaints Department box. American Default is independent of Fay.

Fay Servicing customer service and mortgage assistance

800-495-7166

Fay’s assistance and general contact pages use this number.

Listed on fayservicing.com · checked Oct 23, 2026

Written servicing complaints; not identified as a federal error-notice address

Fay Servicing, LLC
Attn: Complaints Department
P.O. Box 815548
Farmers Branch, TX 75381

Fay labels this box Complaints Department.

Listed on fayservicing.com · checked Oct 23, 2026

Fay’s Loan Solution Center offers a mortgage assistance application. A borrower can upload documents and see an application’s status after signing in.

Behind on a Fay Servicing mortgage?

A HUD-approved housing counselor is a free adviser, approved by the government, who can go over your options with your mortgage company. Call 800-569-4287 or visit consumerfinance.gov/mortgagehelp.

Fay services loans for owners of the debt

Fay Servicing, LLC handles mortgage accounts under its own name. Its privacy policy lists Fay Financial, Fay Management and Fay Investments as related U.S. legal entities. It also names Genstone companies as affiliates under common ownership or control. The policy does not name a parent company.

Fay’s privacy notice distinguishes the servicer from a third-party owner of the loan. Our reading of Fay’s specialty-servicing business is that loan owners can hand Fay loans already behind on payments. Fay describes its focus as distressed and at-risk home loans, and a filed servicing agreement names a separate loan owner. We have not measured how many loans were behind when Fay took them on.

Read complaint issues →

44.7% of Fay complaints concern payment hardship

Since May 1, 2017, 44.7% of Fay mortgage complaints are labeled “Struggling to pay mortgage.” The typical share was 23.1% among 74 other mortgage companies with at least 200 mortgage complaints.

Payment-process complaints make up 47.0%, below the 50.8% peer median. The higher hardship share and lower payment-process share point in different directions; neither measures Fay’s incoming loan mix.

Among 643 Fay payment-process complaints with a subissue, 28.1% concerned trying to communicate with the company. Another 21.9% concerned the payment process itself.

Fay hardship complaints: 44.7%, versus 23.1% at peers

Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Consumer Complaint Database, mortgage complaints received since May 1, 2017 · American Default
Download
American Default Research

Compare equal periods →

Fay complaints fell from 448 to 344

The CFPB received 344 Fay Servicing mortgage complaints from October 21, 2025, through October 20, 2026. It received 448 in the prior 12 months. The CFPB ended Fay’s 2024 order on July 1, 2025, during the earlier window.

The decrease is 104 complaints across matching 12-month spans.

Fay Servicing: 448 before, 344 now

0200400600 448Prior 12 months344Current 12 months
Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Consumer Complaint Database, equal 12-month windows ending Oct 20, 2026 · American Default
Download
American Default Research

See annual trend →

Fay’s yearly counts put the recent decline in context

Fay’s complete-year total rose from 405 in 2024 to 434 in 2025, its highest annual count in this series. The 2026 bar counts 267 complaints through October 20.

Fay Servicing: 434 in 2025 and 267 through October 20, 2026

0200400600 ’14 ’16 ’18 ’20 ’22 ’24 ’26
Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Consumer Complaint Database, mortgage complaints received 2014–2026 · American Default
Download
American Default Research

Read response record →

Fay’s timely-response share trails typical mortgage companies

Among 32 other mortgage companies with at least 200 complaints in the latest 12 months, the typical company answered every complaint on time. Fay answered 343 of 344 complaints on time, or 99.7%.

Among Fay complaints received since January 2025, 99.6% closed with an explanation. None closed with monetary relief. These are the company-response categories recorded by the CFPB.

Ask for help →

How can a Fay borrower request assistance?

Fay’s get-help page links to an assistance application and a borrower form. Its phone line is 800-495-7166. The company can explain which documents it wants for a particular loan. The Loan Solution Center also provides document upload and application-status views.

A free HUD-approved housing counselor can help review an application and compare options.

  1. Use Fay’s Loan Solution Center

    Fay says borrowers can apply for mortgage assistance, submit documents and track application status through the center.

    Source: Fay Get Help

  2. Confirm the written-request address

    Fay publishes a complaints-department box. A federal notice of error uses any address the servicer has designated for that purpose, so the statement matters.

    Source: Fay Contact Us

Read the rules →

Where can a Fay Servicing borrower complain?

Fay’s contact page lists complaint routes in Hawaii, Minnesota, New York and Texas. The CFPB complaint form is available nationally.

Entrance to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau building in Washington.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau accepts mortgage complaints from borrowers. CFPB contact page

Photo: G. Edward Johnson, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

Read the public record →

Fay Servicing regulator and court record

Fay has two separate CFPB consent orders. The 2017 matter concerned foreclosure protections; the 2024 matter found later violations and failure to meet parts of the earlier order. The 2017 order set a borrower-redress ceiling. The 2024 order imposed a penalty, a separate redress payment and a technology investment.

  1. Mar 25, 2026

    U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit Appellate decision affirming dismissal

    The court affirmed dismissal of claims over short-sale denial letters and responses to error notices. It held that the pleaded claims did not state a violation of the cited federal statutes.

    Admitted wrongdoing? No admission; this was a contested court ruling.

    No penalty or borrower award in the appellate decision.

    Status: Dismissal affirmed March 25, 2026. · Eleventh Circuit opinion, docket 24-12564

  2. Aug 21, 2024

    Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Administrative consent order

    The bureau found violations of mortgage-servicing laws and its 2017 order. The agency terminated the 2024 order on July 1, 2025, after Fay fulfilled several obligations.

    Admitted wrongdoing? Fay neither admitted nor denied the findings, except facts establishing bureau jurisdiction.

    $2 million civil penalty paid; $3 million paid to the bureau for borrower redress. A separate $2 million technology and compliance investment was required, not imposed as a penalty.

    Status: Order terminated July 1, 2025. The bureau listed redress distribution as ongoing from March 6, 2026. · CFPB 2024 Fay case and termination

  3. Jun 7, 2017

    Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Administrative consent order

    The bureau found that Fay failed to provide required foreclosure protections while some borrowers sought relief.

    Admitted wrongdoing? Fay admitted only the facts needed to establish the bureau’s jurisdiction.

    $1.15 million was the maximum borrower redress required. The case summary states no separate civil penalty.

    Status: The CFPB says its payment program ended in July 2023. · CFPB 2017 Fay case

What do the federal written-request rules say?

These deadlines describe ordinary cases; exceptions and extensions apply.

  1. Written requests: route and response times

    Fay labels its Farmers Branch box for complaints; it does not label that box as a federal error-notice address. Regulation X section 35 requires error-notice acknowledgment within five business days and a substantive response within 30. Section 36 sets 30 business days for information requests and 10 for owner identification.

    Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Regulation X, sections 35 and 36

Questions about Fay Servicing

Where does Fay direct a borrower seeking payment assistance?

Fay’s Loan Solution Center has an application entry and a way to upload documents. Customer care is at 800-495-7166 during the hours on the contact card.

Which state complaint agencies does Fay name?

Fay’s contact page lists Hawaii, Minnesota, New York and Texas routes. The national CFPB complaint form is a separate option.

What money did Fay’s 2024 CFPB order require?

It required a $2 million civil penalty and $3 million for borrower redress. A separate $2 million technology investment was part of the order, not a penalty.

How are Fay Financial and Fay Servicing related?

Fay’s privacy notice lists both as separate U.S. legal entities. It also names Genstone companies as affiliates under common ownership or control.

Protect yourself from scams

The FTC and CFPB describe these warning signs and the rules behind them:

  1. Upfront fees for promised relief are a warning sign. Under FTC mortgage-assistance rules, most companies that sell mortgage help cannot charge until a homeowner accepts a written offer from the mortgage company or lender. A separate FTC rule covers debt-relief companies that sell by phone and ties fees to a completed debt arrangement. It bars a fee until at least one debt has been settled or changed, the customer agrees to the arrangement, and the customer has made a payment under it. The FTC describes a narrow exception for lawyers who give help as part of the practice of law and are licensed in the state where the client or dwelling is. The lawyer follows that state's rules for attorneys, and advance fees are placed in a client trust account before services begin under state trust-account rules.
  2. HUD-approved foreclosure-prevention counseling is free. HUD’s national counselor line is 800-569-4287. The CFPB counselor finder lists agencies and their services. If an organization charges for help described as free HUD counseling, the CFPB finder can verify the agency and its listed services before any payment.
  3. A request to sign over a deed is a warning sign. The CFPB identifies title-transfer schemes among foreclosure-relief scams. Signing over title can mean losing ownership of the home; a lawyer can explain what a proposed document would do.
  4. Foreclosure protections depend on timing and the loan. Regulation X generally bars the first foreclosure notice or filing on a principal-residence loan until the borrower is more than 120 days behind, subject to exceptions. A complete assistance application can delay some foreclosure steps, but that depends on when it arrives; it does not necessarily stop every step. The CFPB warns about promises to “save” a home.

Fraud reports: CFPB · FTC · state attorney general offices.

Free help if you're behind

Housing counselors approved by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development work at nonprofit agencies. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes free foreclosure-avoidance counseling, including help with mortgage-company conversations and available options (CFPB).

  • HUD-approved housing counselors

    Nationwidehud.gov

    Our help directory lists 1,010 agencies approved for foreclosure counseling, by state.

  • Legal aid

    Every statelsc.gov

    Nonprofit law offices give free civil legal help to people with low incomes. Our help directory lists 120 legal aid organizations funded by the Legal Services Corporation.

Every figure on this page, with its period and the CFPB filter behind it, in one file. Free to use with credit to American Default Research.

Download the figures (CSV) · JSON

Cite this Fay Servicing hardship complaints: 44.7% of its mortgage record · American Default Research · americandefault.org/servicers/fay-servicing/

Sources and method

We gather the data, run the numbers and research each company ourselves. The CFPB publishes complaints without verifying every borrower account. Counts use the CFPB company name “Fay Servicing, LLC” and the dates printed beside each chart. Peer medians use company labels drawn from American Default’s servicer directory and Valon. Each peer has at least 200 mortgage complaints in the period measured by its chart. Updated: October 2026 · Next review expected: January 2027.

We write with assistance from AI tools. Figures come from the data and sources named on this page.